The first universities in Europe with a form of corporate/guild structure were the University of Bologna (1088), the University of Paris (c. 1150, later associated with the Sorbonne), the University of Oxford (1167), the University of Modena (1175), the University of Palencia (1208), the University of Cambridge (1209), the University of Salamanca (1218), the University of Montpellier (1220), the University of Padua (1222), the University of Naples Federico II (1224), and the University of Toulouse (1229).—Wikipedia.

Universities as corporate bodies are institutions with amazing longevity.  They have a demonstrated record of adaptability, re-invention, and expansion. They have seen the rise and fall of Feudalism, the Reformation, the growth of capitalism, expanding suffrage, Communism, Nazism, and innumerable break-through technologies (including print, telescopes, radio, TV, etc.) One does not show such durability by exhibiting special moral courage nor by clinging to the status quo. Rather, one does so by shrewd opportunism and a firm eye on strategies that ensure long-term survival.  None of this is to deny that there are not failed (e.g. Palencia) or zombie universities in which the academic ethos struggles against clientism, nepotism, state control, and a whole list of -isms taht promote mediocrity (many of which intimately familiar to us in Europe). 

Only a fool bets against universities. One has to be a huge fool to bet against North American universities; these thrive in an extremely, competitive environment. To be clear: their thriving can come at the expense of many academics (e.g., adjuncts); their thriving is compatible with being a rich source of profit to alternative parties (e.g., Apple); their thriving is also compatible with providing governments with tools to spy on the whole world (enuff said). What's good for universities is not necessarily an unmitigated good. Now, for that whole, amazing history of the university, philosophy has had some place in the curriculum. Nothing lasts forever, of course, and philosophy may have changed essence along the way…because just saying.

Posted in ,

5 responses to “Pep-talk of the day”

  1. jackie taylor Avatar
    jackie taylor

    Eric,
    Would very much like to see something on the current state of the universities in Greece, if you can find a good informed opinion on it.

    Like

  2. Neil Levy Avatar
    Neil Levy

    I am not betting against universities. But nor am I betting for them. I think there is a real question about the extent to which the past is a guide to the future in human history, especially in modernity in which “all that’s solid melts into air”. I suspect that universities now face unprecedented challenges in unprecedented circumstances (they may have faced unprecedented challenges in unprecedented circumstances before, but these are new challenges and circumstances and their success in meeting them in the past does not predict success in the future).
    Of course, one also needs criteria for “universities”. The institutions you mention are very different from the premodern institutions with which they are continuous. I suspect one could make a case for the claim that the university has died multiple deaths.

    Like

  3. - Avatar

    What about the Academy? Justinian seemed to put the kibosh on that. Seems like a reasonable bet.

    Like

  4. Mark Lance Avatar

    What Neil said. I think that barring total social collapse – hardly a negligible possibility in the face of climate change – there is very high probability of the continued existence of institutions continuous with all the major US universities for centuries. But what form they will take as they pursue their shrewd opportunism is quit another question. A future in which the overwhelming majority are technical training institutions for corporate drones, staffed by their own corporate drones, with a tiny few elite playgrounds for potential rules spiced up with the occasional genius is absolutely not one that we should discount. Whether we want to call that a survival of universities is probably not an important question.

    Like

  5. dmf Avatar
    dmf

    heh. when I read hereabouts the headline that MOOCs were heading into corporate training I thought of course that is the logical next step for “higher” ed in our times…

    Like

Leave a reply to dmf Cancel reply