by Eric Schwitzgebel

here!

This mega-list of about 360 recommendations is compiled from the lists I’ve been rolling out on The Splintered Mind over the past several weeks. Thirty-four professional philosophers and two prominent science fiction / speculative fiction (SF) authors with graduate training in philosophy each contributed a list of ten personal favorite “philosophically interesting” SF works, with brief “pitches” for each recommended work.

I have compiled two mega-lists, organized differently. One mega-list is organized by contributor, so that you can see all of Scott Bakker’s recommendations, then all of Sara Bernstein’s recommendations, etc. It might be useful to skim through to see whose tastes you seem to share and then look at what other works that person recommends.

The other mega-list is organized by author (or director or TV series), to highlight authors (directors / TV shows) who were most often recommended by the list contributors.

The most recommended authors were:

Recommended by 11 contributors:

  • Ursula K. Le Guin

Recommended by 8:

  • Philip K. Dick


Recommended by 7:

  • Ted Chiang
  • Greg Egan

Recommended by 5:

  • Isaac Asimov
  • Robert A. Heinlein
  • China Miéville
  • Charles Stross

Recommended by 4:

  • Jorge Luis Borges
  • Ray Bradbury
  • P. D. James
  • Neal Stephenson

Recommended by 3:

  • Edwin Abbott
  • Douglas Adams
  • Margaret Atwood
  • R. Scott Bakker
  • Iain M. Banks
  • Octavia Butler
  • William Gibson
  • Stanisław Lem
  • George R. R. Martin
  • Larry Niven
  • George Orwell (Eric A. Blair)
  • Kurt Vonnegut

The most recommended directors / TV shows were:


Recommended by 7:

  • Star Trek: The Next Generation

Recommended by 5:

  • Christopher Nolan (Memento, The Prestige, Batman: The Dark Knight, Inception)

Recommended by 4:

  • Ridley Scott (Blade Runner)

Recommended by 3:

  • Futurama
  • Duncan Jones (Moon, Source Code)
  • Andrew Niccol (Gattaca)
  • Paul Verhoeven (Total Recall, Starship Troopers)
  • Andy & Lana Wachowski (The Matrix and sequels)
Reactions, corrections, and futher suggestions welcome (as always) in the comments section.

[image source]

[Cross-posted at The Splintered Mind]

Posted in

17 responses to “Philosophical SF: Thirty-Six Philosophers’ Recommendations”

  1. Charles Pigden Avatar

    No Orson Scott Card? I would put ‘Ender’s Game’ and ‘Ender’s Shadow’ high on my list.

    Like

  2. Carl Sachs Avatar

    Are you still accepting submissions?

    Like

  3. Eric Schwitzgebel Avatar

    Charles: Card made the longer list. I agree that Ender’s Game is terrific.

    Like

  4. Eric Schwitzgebel Avatar

    Carl: Yes! I hope that more submissions will trickle in. If so, I’ll spin them out in batches of four on my blog and update the mega-lists. I’d love to see the lists get longer, both incorporating a broader range of works and bringing more authors/works into the multiply-cited category. (Email me.)

    Like

  5. william lewis Avatar
    william lewis

    James Tiptree Jr. should be on any list science fiction with philosophical themes, especially around gender, bodies, pain, environment, etc.

    Like

  6. Eric Schwitzgebel Avatar

    Yes, Tiptree is on the longer list, recommended by two (Rachael Briggs and Eric Kaplan).

    Like

  7. Dave Maier Avatar

    Lem is essential. Imaginary Magnitude blew my mind back in the day. Also A Perfect Vacuum and The Chain of Chance. And the Pirx the Pilot stories. Ooh, and Fiasco.

    Like

  8. Charles Pigden Avatar

    Well I am glad that Card at least made the long-list. But it’s not just Ender’s Game & the other books in the Enderverse. For the Philosophy of personal identity, avatars and copying, etc Orson Scott Card’s short story ‘Fat Farm’ is hard to beat. (What happens when you copy somebody’s memories and consciousness into a fresh new body but don’t discard the old one?)
    And I concur with William Lewis Rachael Briggs and Eric Kaplan about James Tiptree junior

    Like

  9. Philippe Lemoine Avatar
    Philippe Lemoine

    What about Kim Stanley Robinson’s Mars trilogy?

    Like

  10. anon Avatar
    anon

    oh dear… this is not going to help philosophy’s reputation as a haven for straight white nerdy dudes.

    Like

  11. Eric Schwitzgebel Avatar

    Haven’t read “Fat Farm”! Thanks for the suggestion.

    Like

  12. Eric Schwitzgebel Avatar

    I read his 2312 last summer — terrific book! Sadly, Kim Stanley Robinson didn’t seem to make anyone’s list of ten.

    Like

  13. Eric Schwitzgebel Avatar

    Well… yeah. But at least we love Ursula!

    Like

  14. Philippe Lemoine Avatar
    Philippe Lemoine

    I don’t read a lot of sci-fi and I haven’t read 2312, but I highly recommend Kim Stanley Robinson’s Mars trilogy. It’s pretty realistic, has a ton of interesting characters and involves a lot of political/social themes. I’m really surprised that nobody mentioned it, though admittedly it’s a very special kind of sci-fi.

    Like

  15. MPGuy Avatar
    MPGuy

    No love (very little love?) for non-western sci-fi! Mamoru Oshii’s films are pretty much required viewing for anything on Technology and Philosophy as is the series Serial Experiments Lain.

    Like

  16. Amy Avatar
    Amy

    James Tiptree, Jr.

    Like

Leave a reply to Charles Pigden Cancel reply